When the former defender stepped into the role as the club's head coach in January, he faced little time to find his feet. A packed match calendar signified a phased integration to his squad was impossible.
Local press pointed out the challenges he would face, specifically handling a locker room packed with some of football's biggest personalities.
But building solid bonds with the footballers did not seem to faze the ex- Liverpool defender.
"It's not an aspect that troubles me a lot," Arbeloa stated at his first news conference.
Two months on, he claims those rapports are strengthening and the performances on the pitch are following.
Building Bonds
In March, the Madrid boss guided his team to victories against teams coached by top-tier managers: the Portuguese manager's Benfica, Pep Guardiola's Manchester City and the Argentine's Atletico.
Real Madrid continue to be four points behind La Liga leaders their arch-rivals, with a potentially title-deciding El Clasico in May, while their Champions League campaign proceeds with a quarter-final tie against Bayern Munich.
Real's results are on the up and the chemistry between the coach and squad are building.
"I'm getting to know the individuals better and better," commented Arbeloa after Real Madrid's 3-2 success against local foes Atletico Madrid last week.
"I came in at a time when I virtually had insufficient time to train with the squad, to understand where they felt comfortable, and to see how they gelled with one another."
He acknowledged the timing of his hiring created fresh difficulties.
"In my case, it's challenging to arrive mid-season and see how the team works, and that is precisely what has changed over these past eight weeks," he added.
"Now I understand my players personally and professionally, where I can elicit the best display from them, and where I can make adjustments."
Plaudits for Vinicius Jr
One player flourishing under the new manager is the Brazilian winger.
He has been in the starting lineup for 16 of Arbeloa's 17 games at the helm, with his output also improving significantly - he has netted 11 times under the current boss, versus registering just six in 27 appearances under Xabi Alonso.
The coach has focused on restoring the forward's morale, encouraging him to play freely and express himself rather than constraining him systematically.
"I am fortunate to have Vini, he's loved by the supporters. We want to see the Vini who has fun on the pitch, who laughs, who dances… that's the player I want to see," he stated in his initial press conference in charge.
This method contrasts with accounts of friction under the previous manager, with Vinicius being heard to say "I'm going to quit this team" after being replaced in last Clasico.
The new boss has publicly stood up for him, stating clearly he is fully backed by the coaching staff and the dressing room.
"He's one of the most dangerous footballers, if not the deadliest, in the world and he represents what a this club's star is," said the manager.
The Brazilian put talks about his future at the club on hold last summer but, last week, he affirmed his loyalty clear.
"I am solely thinking about Real Madrid and staying here for a long time," he told the press before Brazil's friendly with France.
Valverde Recaptures Form Once More
The Uruguayan midfielder's form has also surged since Arbeloa took charge.
During the tenure of Alonso, he contributed three strikes and seven assists from 31 games.
Ever since the manager's appointment, he has been named in the starting eleven for each of the 17 of his games, scoring on seven occasions and contributing five assists.
A primary cause has been a tactical repositioning back into midfield.
Throughout Alonso's spell, the player at times had difficulty trying to secure a regular place in his natural role, being positioned in unfamiliar positions such as full-back.
While the decision was partly because of injuries to teammates, his displeasure was obvious. "I wasn't made to be a defender," he said.
But now, restored to his natural habitat, Valverde is thriving.
He has scored six goals in just a month, including a three-goal haul against City and a decisive strike in a 3–2 win over their city rivals.
More Players, More Potential?
The manager's prior role as head coach of Real Madrid's reserve team has made incorporating youth prospects into the senior side feel seamless, so it was expected to anticipate him to give emerging talent opportunities.
That happened particularly when the team faced their opponents recently and the coach handed playing time to six youth team graduates.
One player, in especial, has rapidly established himself as one of the manager's most exciting proteges.
Being only 18 years of age and 226 days old, he made history as the youngest footballer in the club's records to start twice in the Champions League latter stages, beating a previous mark by 10 days.
Asked what it signified to see several youth products on the pitch, Arbeloa couldn't hide his delight.
"I believe I can die happy after a evening like tonight," he stated.
"I was just talking to some of them, who were the first players I managed when they were very young, and to be able to give them the chance to perform at the Santiago Bernabeu is a dream come true for me."
While the coach might be familiar with the Castilla players, he acknowledges fitness setbacks have restricted his exposure